Potbelly Sandwich Shop in Ames

Good sandwiches, but not great. Unhealthy but the hot peppers are amazing

Sandwiches are very good! Prices a little high...

Best make your own sub shop ever. My only wish is that the shakes were bigger.

Good service, reliable caterer.

I AM NOT A FAN OF SUBS & SANDWICH SHOPS! I AM A FAN OF POTBELLY!!! The ABSOLUTE BEST I have EVER tasted. We are working @ the University and coworkers chose Potbelly Sandwich. I started to go to Blaze Pizza instead. I'm thankful I stuck with Potbelly's. DELICIOUS 😋! ALL my coworkers agree that this is the BEST sub/sandwich spot we have ever eaten @. I had the flat bread chicken n cheese with bacon, mayo, olive oil and Italian seasoning toasted to perfection..........OH MY GOODNESSS!!!! 2 WORDS......SKRUMP....... SHUSH!!!!! Really nice spot. A little small so get there before the crowd. The strawberry shake was small but good and just enough. You gotta drop in whenever near Iowa State University. Oh! I almost forgot...The service was very fast and pleasant. Friendly smiling faces😊. Your boy The RIBOLOGIST IS OUT ✌🏾

If you order a bowl of soup, it should be a full bowl for the price charged. Secondly what happened to the pot pie crust thats usually on top of said soup?

Great food. Great atmosphere. Little low on seating but I guess being a college town, a good place to grab a good bite.

This Shop has great Sandwiches. I did not see many Potbellies, which was surprising. But if you can get past that, I think you'll really enjoy your meal.

Potbelly sandwiches are very tasty and there are quite a few options. The shakes are also very good.

Would put 0 if that was possible. The manager Savannah is a horribly rude and disorganized. She yells at customers and employees. Will never return to this store.

Had a catering delivery order from this store today to serve a group of 66 women--all were overwhelmingly happy with the sandwiches! I was a little nervous ordering warm sandwiches for a large group, but they did a fantastic job and kept them nice and warm until they were served. Special thanks to Pete for his help as well as the rest of the staff for being so accommodating when I had to make some changes.

Ordered 20 sandwiches for a work meeting, they did a good job with having each labeled for what the sandwhich was and who it went to. The food tasted good and the service was good. Using the online ordering was really easy and quick.

So good! 10/10 would eat there again

Decent food, adore their shakes and pickled peppers and carrots

Decent food but the worst is no parking. When an event gets out it gets busy. You would think they have a history of this and have more staff on hand. Saw a doordash guy have to wait 10 minutes at least. I'd think they be top priority.

Excellent sandwich... Great milk shakes!!

A good sandwich shop with some unique choices. Definitely a step up from the Jimmy Johns/Subways, but worth it. Location is clean and pretty quick to get in and out.

Cute sandwich shop in campus town. There is no parking, so look for any spot you can find along Lincoln Way and walk down there. Sandwiches were good and ready fast. Going to be a busy place once classes start at ISU again. Would be 5 stars if not for lack of parking.

Nice Potbelly. Restaurant was clean and not too busy. Staff was efficient and patient with us ordering. Parking can be difficult given its location directly on Lincoln.

not really impressed. I can get toast at home

Too much of a fast food atmosphere and pizza not that good

I ate once there and was ok. They were nice yet it's like Starbucks behind counter so distant from real service. Food was ok but I ask bread to give to birds yet they wanted money for it so I was disappointed for not being to feed the birds. All I needed was bread that could not be sold to humans!

Just when you thought service couldn’t get any slower, you have the Potbelly staff to prove it can.

Always providing me with good, warm sandwiches and delicious milkshakes.

Had a shake here it was great and it was made with fresh ingredients and just the way I wanted it

Good sandwich, quick, courteous service!

I had the mushroom melt and it was perfect!

Greatsandwiches. I love the bread.

Reasonably priced for a filling meal. Service was quick and the place was kept clean. Staff were super friendly too. I'll definitely be coming back!

Super friendly staff. Good roast beef sandwich. Really excellent broccoli chedder soup. I'll be back!

Great Cuban sandwich. Sat outside on a perfect weather day. Nice convenient place for lunch across from ISU campus.

I love this place so much. The pickle chips are soooo good. The malts are AMAZINGGGG. Also I highly recommend the Mediterranean sandwich.

I was greatly pleased with the pulled pork sandwich. It was tasty and spicy. It is nice that they give you a discount coupon to be used in the next consecutive days.

Good food and fast service. Nice place for soup & a sandwich.

I need to get here more often, great sandwiches and I always have a good experience here.

Great sandwich, slaw and atmosphere!

Unequivocally delicious!!!!!!! I ordered a sandwich known as "The Wreck" and its name certainly preceded the experience; my taste buds were WRECKED with pleasure! The service was speedy and the staff was cordial. I assuredly intend to return one day!

Good sandwiches, using high quality ingredients.

Easily the best sandwich shop in town, Subway and Jimmy Johns are for chumps!

Really great sandwiches.

Great staff. Great food.

The sandwiches are ok - but don't get delivery. We've done it twice, and each time they were 30-60 minutes late, and everything was cold. Then they gave us coupons that can only be redeemed if you go into the store - which doesn't work so well if you aren't already on campus. Today was the final time.

Don't pass up on the hot peppers. They are world class. Very tasty:)

Good sandwiches

We had potbelly last night for dinner. We have had the subs there before and they were always good. My kids really like the shakes also. Well last night I decided to try the Chicken Salad Salad. Its was wonderful. Dont think I have ever had a salad so large. The chicken salad itself was good there were good portions of cheese,grape tomatoes, cucumbers, cranberries etc. And I only finished half mostly without dressing it was that good. My only regret is that I didnt take a picture. The chicken pot pie soup was also delicious! Definitely going back again.

Small shop but quick and efficient. Great sandwiches at a fair price. I plan to go again.

Top of the line sandwich shop. Good bread, great staff. Prices about right for the high quality. Served toasted with customizable toppings.

Love this place! They have very fast service, and the sandwiches are yummy. During the school year, however, this place gets packed, so be ready to find seating elsewhere.

I ordered and recommend the "A Wreck" sandwich! The fact they have your sandwich run through a toaster oven makes it much better than the other sandwich shops. Milkshakes are very tasty too!

Solid sandwiches and fast service. Maybe not the best sandwich shop in town, but definitely not the worst. If you've got more time downtown deli or west street are better. But if you need a sandwich and have to choose between this jimmy johns or subway, I would say go here 100% of the time.